What is a Pup Pie?
The original Pup Pie dog treat was created by The Lazy Dog Cookie as a birthday treat for your favorite puppers! The Pup Pie is covered in sprinkles making it look super cute and delicious. Pup-Pies are shaped like a round pie that is already divided into individual segments. This way it is easy for all of your doggy birthday guests to get a piece, without a lot of effort.
What is the Original Pup Pie Made of?
The Original Pup-Pie Birthday pie is made of all natural ingredients. The first three ingredients are listed as oat flour, pumpkin, peanut butter. So it is a good bet that the majority of the treat is made up of these great ingredients.
They go on to list the following additional ingredients: Cane Molasses, Vegetable Glycerin, Cinnamon, Ginger, Palm Oil, Cane Sugar, Vanilla, Sunflower Lecithin, Sodium Bicarbonate, Carnauba Wax & Natural Color.
The sprinkles on the pup pie are said to be made up of real fruit pieces.
Are There Different Flavors of Pup Pies
There are three different Pup-Pies that we have seen available. Two of the pies are for your dog's birthday and are labeled as a special treat for your dog. One box is blue for boys and the other is pink for girl dogs. There is also an Adoptiversary version.
While these are different versions, they are just different packaging. We would like to see actual different flavors of the treat. Lazy Dog does have some different flavored treats, so why not make the pies in different flavors???
Can You Put Candles on Your Pup Pie
The Original Pup Pie is somewhat hard, which makes it easy to snap and portion for your dog guests. This does however make it difficult to get your candles into the pie. We tried a couple of different methods and the best we were able to come up with was using a tooth pick, but it really didn't work great. I would recommend skipping the candles and birthday song with the Pup Pie.
More on the Maker of Pup-Pies
The Lazy Dog Cookie company believes in using all natural ingredients in their products. We think this is really important and we love the company's story! They have been making Pup Pies since 2001. All their products are free of wheat, corn, and soy. They also some products that are; grain, meat or egg free.
Alternatives to Pup Pies
If you are looking for other treat options to serve for your pups birthday, look no further. Here are some other dog birthday ideas and what we think of them.
Other Treats on the Market
|Thoughtfully Pets Dog Birthday Cake
This cake is listed on Amazon as a Ginger cake and is listed as corn, dairy, and soy free. While the cake is pretty on the outside, you might not notice that it is hollow and instead of a cake is really more like a dog biscuit in consistency. Since it isn't pre-portioned we like the Pup-Pie Better.
|Cake Mix For Dogs
If you are looking to make your dog's cake you can buy a cake mix off of amazon. We love that you can customize the cake yourself from there. We would again pick the Pup-Pie over the cake mix. If you are going to go through this effort, you might as well start from scratch with one of the recipes below.
Make Your Own Pies for Your Pup
Mini Apple Pup Pies - Source: Spoiled Hounds
11⁄2 cups Oat Flour
1⁄4-1⁄2 cup Water
2 tablespoons Melted Coconut Oil
1⁄2 cup Unsweetened Applesauce or 1 small apple diced
1⁄2 teaspoon Cornstarch
Preheat oven to 350°F. Spray mini muffin tins with non-stick spray.
In a medium bowl, combine oat flour, melted coconut oil, and water. Add a little water at a time until you reach a rollable dough consistency.
Place the dough on a flat surface and roll it out until it is 1⁄4-inch thick.
Using a round cookie cutter about the same width as a regular muffin tin cup, cut out mini crusts. Using the
leftover crust, cut small strips to lay them across the tops of the mini apple pies to form a criss cross lattice
Gently press mini crusts into the bottom of the muffin cup wells and up the sides.
Place the filling ingredients in a bowl and stir until combined.
Equally divide the filling mixture into the cups.
Lay strips of dough in a criss cross pattern on top of the filling.
Bake for 20 to 25 minutes.
Remove the pies from the muffin tin and cool completely before serving to your dog.
Mini Pumpkin Doggy Pies - Source: Rover
2 1/2 cups rolled oats
3/4 cup unsweetened applesauce
3/4 cup unsweetened pumpkin puree
Plain Greek yogurt
Preheat oven to 350o
Pulse rolled oats in a food processor until they are a floury consistency.
In a mixing bowl, stir together the oat flour and applesauce until a nice dough ball forms.
Divide the dough into 24 equal sized pieces.
Spray mini muffin tin with non-stick spray.
Place a ball in each well of the mini muffin tin and press to flatten.
Bake the crust for 8 min or until just starting to color.
Let cool before removing from pan.
Peel and mash the banana in a large bowl.
Add the pumpkin puree and stir to combine.
Divide the filling among the pie crusts and top with a dollop of yogurt.
Local Dog Bakeries
Local dog bakeries are some of my favorite places to visit with my dog. There is always something new to try. You get that local connection to other dog lovers in the area. Additionally you can usually pick up something extra while you are there, as they usually have a whole bunch of cool pet products.
While I know it won't help all of our readers, my favorite pet bakery of all time is Happy Dog Bakery in Downers Grove, IL. They do ship products, however that takes away some of that local charm I was talking about.
Are Pup Pies Safe for My Dog
Pup Pies have been a popular treat for dog parties for years. There are tons of great reviews for the product suggesting that the product has been safely used and enjoyed.
Product Recall in 2023
In April of 2023 The Lazy Dog issued what some call a voluntary recall of Pup Pies after multiple reviews on Amazon. The reviews stated that dogs became sick after eating the Original Pup Pie Birthday Treat. Pup Pies with the lot number: 022297 Sell By 102024, were affected.
In a Post on Lazy Dog's Website the company expressly discusses that there was no recall and the products were removed out of an abundance of caution and to perform testing. They worked with the FDA to confirm that the treats had no toxins, pesticides, e-coli, or salmonella.
Reviews also stated that Amazon Sellers were still selling the affected Pies after the company notice had been issued.
Final Verdict on Pup Pies
I personally would allow my pup to eat a Pup-Pie at one of his dog friends birthday parties. But at the same time, if I was throwing the dog party...I would much rather provide a treat that I either made and know exactly what is in it or a treat that was made by a quality local dog bakery. If you have the time and ability go with one of those options, however Pup-Pies are a great choice if you just want to order something and have it show up right away!
If You Enjoyed Reading About Pup Pies You May Enjoy:
|Best Christmas Gifts For Dog and Dog Lovers: 2023
If you've already got your dog's birthday pie and present. Do you have that perfect gift for Christmas? Check out our best holiday gifts for 2023 and make sure that you get the best presents available for 2023!
|Dakota 283 G3 Kennel Review
If you are looking for a great travel crate for your pup, check out our review of the Dakota 283 G3.
The article above contains Affiliate Links from Amazon and other companies. If you visit their site and buy the product, we will get a small commission. Please know that we only recommend products we love and would never recommend a product we think is less than great. We look at and try hundreds of products before we ever recommend them to our clients!